Post copy: Anthony Caravella, who lives with an intellectual disability, was arrested for sexual assault and murder when he 15. On December 28, 1983, Caravella was arrested for failing to show up in court for a grand theft auto charge, and while he was in custody, police began asking him about the murder and assault of Ada Jankowski—Caravella gave three different, conflicting confessions, all of which had incorrect details about the case. He went to court anyway.
With his confession as evidence, the prosecution accused Caravella of the crimes, despite DNA evidence being inconclusive, and questioned a friend of his who claimed Caravella was at the scene of the crime. Caravella’s attorneys argued that the police beat and threatened him, which is why he confessed. The jury convicted Anthony Caravella to life in prison when he was just 16 years old. In 2010, after 26 years, the actual assailant was proven and Anthony Caravella was exonerated.
This case has been cited as a reason to record interrogations, in order to hold police accountable and protect the accused. Most false confessions occur after the 6 hours of an interrogation—Anthony Caravella’s interrogation lasted five days.
24 states have already made recorded interrogation required. To join the fight for recorded interrogations, visit: www.innocenceproject.org/getinvolved/.
Find out whether your state is one of the 24: https://innocenceproject.org/false-confessions-recording-interrogations/.